Yeh sawaal aksar aata hai: agar group sirf baat karne ka hai toh professional tak pohanchne kyun nahi dete? Is page mein hum samjhayenge ke aise groups ka asli maqsad kya hai aur aap apne ilaaj ke liye sahi raasta kyun talash karein.
Maine ek mental health group join kiya jahan ek professional ne medicine aur sessions lene ko kaha. Lekin group ke rule ke wajah se mujhe unka number nahi diya gaya. Ab mujhe lagta hai ke sirf baat karne se depression nahi jaata, toh aise group ka kya faida jab hum asli madad nahi le sakte?
Aap jo keh rahe hain woh bilkul sahi hai. Agar ek group sirf baat karne tak rok de aur asli professional help tak na pahunchne de, toh uska faida kya? Yeh frustration aapka jaiz hai — aapne wahan ek professional se suna ke aapko medicine aur sessions ki zaroorat hai, lekin jab aap ne us tak pahunchne ka zariya manga toh aap ko roka gaya. Yeh aapke saath insaaf nahi.
Kai mental health groups ka yeh rule hota hai ke members ek doosre ko private advice na dein, kyunki woh kisi ki professional responsibility nahi le sakte. Lekin yahan uljhan yeh hai ke ek professional ne khud aapko treatment ka mashwara diya — phir us tak pahunchne se rokna aapko beech mein latka dene jaisa hai. Yeh rule shayad group ko legal issues se bachane ke liye hai, lekin aapke haq mein nahi.
Aapne jo kiya woh sahi kiya — sawaal puchhna aur madad dhundhna. Agar koi group aapko asli madad tak nahi pahunchne deta, toh aap wahan se bahar nikal kar kisi registered professional ko directly contact karein. Aap akela nahi hain, aur Zara yahan hai agar kabhi baat karni ho.
Names and cities shown here are examples. Every question is published anonymously — we never ask for, store or show the name, city or contact details of the person who wrote it.
You don't have to work this out from an article. We're free, private, and here right now — in English, Urdu or Roman Urdu. No signup, no waiting, no judgement.
Other questions people asked about the same thing, answered the same way.
