You've asked a great question about the similarities and differences between depression and beliefs about jinnat. Let's break it down. Many people wonder if these are two sides of the same coin.
Yeh quote bilkul sahi nahi hai, magar is mein aik haqeeqat chhupi hui hai. Dehati ilaqon mein aksar zehni aur jazbaati takleef ko "jinnat" ka naam de diya jata hai, aur shehron mein usi tarah ki takleef ko "depression" keh kar label lagaya jata hai. Lekin iska matlab yeh hargiz nahi ke jinnat aur depression aik hi cheez hain — jinnat ka aqeedah iman ka masla hai, aur depression aik zehni bemari hai. Dono ko aik karna na sahi hai, na munasib.
Quote ka maqsad shayad yeh batana tha ke dono jagah insaan takleef mein hota hai, bas us takleef ka naam alag alag rakha jata hai. Yeh baat kuch had tak durust hai — dehat mein koi aurat "haath aaya" ya "peet diya" keh kar samajh se bahar ho jati hai, aur shehar mein koi aurat "depression hai" keh kar ghar mein khamosh kar di jati hai. Dono surat mein asal masla yeh hai ke us insaan ki takleef suni nahi ja rahi, aur na samjhi ja rahi hai.
Toh is tarah samjhiye — quote mein likhne wale ne do alag cheezon ko mila diya, lekin unke peeche ka dard aik hai. Agr koi aapko aisi baat batae, to iska matlab yeh nahi ke jinnat aur depression aik hain, balke yeh ke har taraf logon ko sachhi samajh aur sachhi madad ki zaroorat hai. Jo naam bhi ho — jinnat ho, depression ho, ya bilkul bhi naam na ho — takleef ko pehchanne aur us par baat karne ki zaroorat hai.
Names and cities shown here are examples. Every question is published anonymously — we never ask for, store or show the name, city or contact details of the person who wrote it.
You don't have to work this out from an article. We're free, private, and here right now — in English, Urdu or Roman Urdu. No signup, no waiting, no judgement.
Other questions people asked about the same thing, answered the same way.
